Pick the Best Individual NBA Player Contest Poll

[Scott "JSA" McLaughlin]

It was a very very difficult job but i have selected what "I" consider the best 6 individual collections on the net. Now what I need you guys to do is select me a winner between these 5 contestants.


For those who didnt make my top 6 list, please dont take my decision personal. Everyone and I mean everyone has fantastic collections and should be proud of their hard work. Here are a few notes to some members explaining why they didnt make my cut.

mutombo_fan - You have a amazing collection. If your collection could have been organized a bit more so i knew which each card was I would have rated your collection higher. Still a amazing collection and I look for you to make some noise next time we run this contest.

White Ice- Without scans to see your cards, I was unable to rate your collection. Your list of cards is impressive next time hopefully you can add some scans.

126andy- I know your collection is probably amazing, unfortunately i couldnt get password access to it. I asked others to try and get in, and they werent able to either. Sorry about this bud, but i was unable to consider your collection because i didnt have access.

Muskajag- OMG! Amazing amazing collection. I just didnt see enough of a balance as it seemed some rookie cards where missing. But youve got one heck of a collection my friend!

JSA- I think my Jrich Collection is good, but due to all the great collections, I took mine out of the hunt.

To anyone else i missed who i didnt select, if you have any questions feel free to reply here. I was only taking one collection per member, so those who submitted more than one i didnt look at.

Ok guys here are my picks! Feel free to reply to this thread with your top 5 picks just so we can see how others view the collections. Voting will end this Friday!!

Here is a look at the collections

http://www.hoopscollector.com/forum/...3&page=1&pp=10

Thanks
JSA

[Amare_to_Dajuan]

damn, i thought my collection is definitely better than half of those(especially the najera collection, no offense)
did i get skipped over or somethin

[Scott "JSA" McLaughlin]

It was a very difficult decision, i think Amare to Dujuan, Big Ben and The Franchise all could have been in top 5 as well. As these 3 had some really strong collections. For me Jazz, Baljit and Najera collections are very similar in that they have almost every card of each player. Frank won his spot in the top 5 due to his Carter rc collection being PSA 9 or better (no small acheivement) and Q.Richardson03 seemed to have a great collection of cards from refractor versions of rookies and etc.


JSA

[Scott "JSA" McLaughlin]

Amare_to_Dajuan

You are obviously entitled to your opinion. But thats how i saw the collections. Feel free to reply with your top 5. Please be respectful to the other members and their collections though. This is for fun guys so lets not get to personal or over sensative about this. Also Amare_to_Dajuan some of your scans had lots of cards in one scan. Made it difficult for me to understand what you had, plus some of the scans with multiple cards had a title like "inserts" or etc. So i guess I was looking for a better definition of what each card was.


JSA

[Amare_to_Dajuan]

ok, thx for the explanation

also dont want to be a jerk or nething but bal only has autos and contest says mixed variety (bal, no offense hopefully, u have the most amazing collection!) and the najera collection is like almost complete cuz theres only 132 cards of him (great collection but less cards to get to to get all of em) :/
i have over 200 cards of a more expensive player(more auto's, more gu, more rc's)
i just thought it was a fact that i would get up there

[Amare_to_Dajuan]

Originally Posted by jsa

Amare_to_Dajuan

You are obviously entitled to your opinion. But thats how i saw the collections. Feel free to reply with your top 5. Please be respectful to the other members and their collections though. This is for fun guys so lets not get to personal or over sensative about this. Also Amare_to_Dajuan some of your scans had lots of cards in one scan. Made it difficult for me to understand what you had, plus some of the scans with multiple cards had a title like "inserts" or etc. So i guess I was looking for a better definition of what each card was.


JSA

fully understood

[Muskajag]

Just to clarify...
I currently haven't added any GU, RCs, #'d, inserts, or base to my page b/c it would be an INCREDIBLE hassle b/c there are so many (and I am a perfectionist when it comes to cards). I really should get scans of my two Kidd Finest RCs and some of my Jefferson RCs tho...I'll def make more than a splash next time around

[Amare_to_Dajuan]

and here are my top five:
amare to dajuan
jazz1232dc
thefranchise
duncanonyou21
muskajag or mutumbo

[Q.Richardson03]

Congrats to everyone who made the cut and good luck!

amare to dajuan, no offense taken. You have a sweet collection, one of the best. I'll be honest as I didnt think I wouldve made the top 6 (yeah, theres's 6 collections, not 5). I guess I lucked out.