Do you think i got a good replacement for my auto redemption

truffleshuffle · 03-25-2008, 10:26 AM

Been along time since i posted anything and im getting back into collecting again.

In 2005 I pulled a2005 donruss classics mike ditak significant signatures auto #erd out of 50 As of last week he still has not signed anything. I desided to have the change out for something else since i figured he would not sign the card any time soon and after two years i just got tired of waiting.

They asked me who i collected and i told them my two main players i collect Barry Sanders and Adrian Peterson but i also said i know that the mike ditka may not have a bv of those two players and i can understand not getting a auto of them but do the best you can to get a suitable autograph redemption.

I did get a card of a player i collect Adrian Peterson but its a jersey card.It is a nice card and i like it but I am a bit disapointed in not getting a auto for auto exchange on a auto redemption of a hall of famer. there is a scan of the perterson on my photobucket at the bottom of my football game used section.

fuser · 03-25-2008, 10:47 AM

ditka or another hof player would have been nice but they did get you someone you collect atleast

truffleshuffle · 03-25-2008, 11:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fuser

ditka or another hof player would have been nice but they did get you someone you collect atleast

Yes i did get someone i collect but would you be disapointed by not getting a autograph for a autogaph?? I feel bad for complaning but would you complain?

**ctkenjr** · 03-25-2008, 11:05 AM

Value wise I think you did fine, but tough call as to whether or not it is better than a Ditka /50 auto. Book wise the AP is higher (I know the Ditka doesn't book though - comparing it to other Ditka autos though).

fuser · 03-25-2008, 07:24 PM

i don't worry too much about auto for auto or game used for game used even in trading. as long as i am getting something i need/want it doesn't matter to me.

abalwhite · 03-25-2008, 08:37 PM

You can always sell on the bay and buy a Ditka... every time I look on ebay at an AP it's way out of my price range!!!

stephenheger · 03-26-2008, 12:53 AM

I would have rather had an auto of a HOFer (I think I am one of the few who doesn't even own a Peterson RC) but I think with you collecting him you did good.

Stephen